Skip to Content

 Grand Theft Auto 6  Reviews

GTA 6 Reviews: 99 Critics Score vs 5.4 Player Rating – What's Happening?

99 Critics Score vs 5.4 Player Rating

 Grand Theft Auto 6 


Reviews: 99 Critics Score vs 5.4 Player Rating
What's Happening?

Grand Theft Auto VI was expected to become one of the biggest video game releases in history, but nobody expected such a massive difference between professional critics and ordinary players.

Rockstar Games' latest blockbuster has received extraordinary reviews from gaming publications, earning a near-perfect 99/100 Metascore on Metacritic.

However, the player ratings tell a completely different story.

In a November 21, 2026 morning snapshot, GTA 6 had a user score of just 5.4/10, based on nearly 33,000 user ratings.

How can a game receive almost perfect reviews from critics while thousands of players give it significantly lower scores?

Let's investigate what is happening.

GTA 6 Has a Near-Perfect 99/100 Critics Score

The professional reviews for GTA VI have been overwhelmingly positive.
According to the November 21 Metacritic snapshot, the PlayStation 5 version had a Metascore of 99 out of 100, calculated from 152 critic reviews.

This places GTA VI among the highest-rated video games ever recorded on the platform.

Several major gaming publications have awarded the game their highest possible scores.

Some notable reviews include:

  • IGN – 10/10

  • GameSpot – 10/10

  • Game Informer – 10/10

  • Eurogamer – 5/5

  • GamesRadar+ – 5/5

  • The Guardian – 5/5

Critics have particularly praised Rockstar's attention to detail, the enormous open world, character development and the relationship between Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos.

For many reviewers, GTA VI represents a major achievement in open-world game design.



Why Are Players Giving GTA 6 a 5.4/10 Rating?

This is where things become interesting.

Despite the outstanding professional reviews, the player score was considerably lower.

In the November 21 morning snapshot:

  • Critics' score: 99/100

  • Players' score: 5.4/10

  • Total user ratings: 32,996

  • Positive user ratings: 47%

  • Mixed user ratings: 8%

  • Negative user ratings: 46%

These numbers reveal a surprisingly divided audience.

However, the score is not permanent. Other reports later on November 21 recorded the user rating around 5.5 as additional reviews arrived.



The 30 FPS Controversy

One of the biggest discussions surrounding GTA VI is its frame-rate performance.

The game targets 30 frames per second on consoles, including the PlayStation 5 Pro.

Many players expected Rockstar's latest release to offer a 60 FPS performance mode, especially considering the game's high price and next-generation visuals.

Some players have also reported frame-rate drops during demanding scenes.

This has become a significant point of criticism, even among people who appreciate the game's graphics and world design.



Story, Characters and Gameplay Are Also Being Debated

Another source of disagreement is the game's creative direction.

GTA VI introduces Jason and Lucia as its central protagonists, with their relationship playing an important role in the story.

Many critics have praised their chemistry and the emotional depth of the narrative.

However, some players have expressed dissatisfaction with the story's pacing, character portrayal and certain narrative choices.

Other criticism focuses on the opening hours, which some reviewers describe as slower than expected.

There are also disagreements about the game's themes, representation and direction.

These reactions are subjective, and not every negative review is necessarily part of a coordinated campaign.



Is GTA 6 Being Review-Bombed?

Review bombing is another major topic surrounding the game's player ratings.

Some Rockstar fans believe that groups of users are deliberately submitting extremely low ratings to damage the game's reputation.

Reports have highlighted large numbers of zero-score reviews, including some that contain little meaningful discussion of gameplay.

There is also an important difference between Metacritic and certain gaming storefronts: Metacritic user reviews do not require proof that someone purchased the game.

This means people can submit ratings without necessarily owning or completing GTA VI.

However, it would be inaccurate to assume that every negative rating is fake.

Some players have genuine complaints about performance, controls, story pacing and other aspects of the experience.

The available evidence does not establish exactly how many ratings are coordinated or submitted in bad faith.



How Does GTA 6 Compare With Previous Rockstar Games?

Rockstar has an impressive history of critically acclaimed releases.

Here is how some of its major games compare on Metacritic's user-score history, according to the reported figures:

GameUser Score
GTA San Andreas9.1/10
Red Dead Redemption 29.0/10
Red Dead Redemption8.9/10
GTA V8.5/10
GTA IV8.4/10
GTA VI5.4/10*

GTA VI figure is a November 21 morning snapshot, not a final or permanent rating.

The difference is particularly surprising because GTA VI's professional critic score is higher than those of its predecessors.



Does the Low User Score Affect GTA 6 Sales?

So far, the available launch figures suggest that the difference in reviews has not prevented an extraordinary commercial launch.

Rockstar reported approximately $3.79 billion in worldwide day-one retail sales.

The company also reported 32.5 million pre-release units.

These figures demonstrate enormous demand for the game, although it is too early to determine whether the negative player reactions will affect its longer-term sales.



Final Verdict: Is GTA 6 Actually Worth Playing?

The difference between the critic score and player score makes GTA VI one of the most interesting gaming discussions of 2026.

Professional reviewers have praised its open world, visual presentation, storytelling and attention to detail.

Meanwhile, some players remain dissatisfied with its frame rate, performance, pacing and creative direction.

A 99 Metascore does not mean every player will love the experience, and a 5.4 user score does not automatically mean the game is bad.

The most useful verdict will come from experiencing the game and evaluating its strengths and weaknesses independently.

What do you think? Does GTA 6 deserve a 99/100, or are the players right to criticize it?

Share your opinion in the comments!

For more gaming news, reviews, walkthroughs and PC gaming guides, keep visiting JERRY MART.

JERRY MART – Your Hub for Gaming, Technology and Digital Entertainment.